Send Us A Message 

About Gaetano’s 

Our Story

Owners Guy Catalano and Milanno Ukehaxhaj started working together almost 25 years ago at Bronx’s famous Arthur Avenue…the “real” Little Italy. They learned the old fashioned deli business from some to the best.

They brought that experience to Stratford, Connecticut nearly 20 years ago. The boys make everything homemade including their amazing fresh mozzarella daily and have their bread delivered from the Bronx’s Addeo and Madonia Bakery’s.  They carry a large assortment of imported and domestic cheeses and cured meats including Boars Head. These ingredients are combined to make amazing dishes and sandwiches that can stand up to the best Italian kitchens…. fugettaboutit!

Guy and Milanno now have three locations in Connecticut.  Stratford, Monroe and Westport.  Come see us and experience a true Arthur Avenue Style Italian deli and caterer and you’ll understand why we’ve been given the honor of being called “number one” in Connecticut!​​